Fred Gardner: Pot Doc Down - Dr. Assad Loses His License
Dr. Assad Loses His License

Pot Doc Down

Weekend Edition
November 13-15, 2009

By FRED GARDNER

Hany Youssef Assad, MD, who has approved cannabis use by some 40,000
patients over the past seven years, is having his license revoked by the
Medical Board of California. The board issued its order Oct. 23. Assad
can no longer see patients after Nov. 23.

The state medical board is under the Department of Consumer Affairs. It
has 21 members, 12 of them MDs appointed by the governor for two- or
four-year terms. The board is staffed by more than 100 career
investigators —gun-carrying "peace officers" whose proper mission is
to bust quacks and incompetents. The investigators act on complaints by
patients —or made on behalf of patients by third parties—
alleging improper treatment by a doctor. When the investigation of the
doctor's practice turns up serious infractions, a lawyer from the
Attorney General's office files an accusation and proposes disciplinary
action. If the doctor chooses not to accept the punishment, he or she
defends his or her practice standards at a hearing held by an
Administrative Law Judge appointed by the board itself. (That's right,
the accuser employs the judge. Welcome to the world of regulatory law.)

The practice standards that must be adhered to by Assad and other
doctors approving cannabis use in California nowadays were defined in a
2004 case involving Tod Mikuriya, MD, the most prominent clinician in
the field. In prosecuting Mikuriya the board employed as an expert
witness a UCSF psychiatrist who had never once approved a patient's use
of cannabis. She opined that Mikuriya's failure, in various cases, to
conduct a physical exam and to keep adequate records, constituted
"extreme departure from the standard of practice."

Mikuriya's expert witness was Philip A. Denney, MD, who at that time had
monitored cannabis use by some 7,500 patients. Denney reviewed
Mikuriya's files and concluded that in every case there was enough
information to support a recommendation for treatment with cannabis.
Every patient had told Mikuriya that they were successfully
self-medicating. ("Conferring legitimacy is a cannabis consultant's most
important role," Mikuriya himself testified.)

The Administrative Law Judge ruled against Mikuriya and the board
promptly made its decision "precedential."

NorCal Healthcare

Hany Assad has been operating a chain, "NorCal Healthcare," with offices
in Oakland, Ukiah, Bakersfield and Arcata. He employs nurse
practitioners and physician's assistants to examine patients. He
flies from city to city in his own small plane, reviews records prepared
by his aides, signs letters of approval, and addresses large groups of
patients on the use of marijuana as medicine.

NorCal Heathcare is now up for sale. Interested parties should contact
Assad's lawyer, Tim Aspinwall, at the Nossaman firm in Sacramento.
Seller strongly motivated.

News that Assad's license was being yanked reached employees in his
Oakland office on Monday, Oct. 26, causing consternation. A call to the
medical board led to a policy decree: letters of approval issued by
Assad post-Oct. 23 would be valid only through Nov. 23. Some patients
demanded refunds, others took the approval letters and went immediately
to get ID cards that would be good for a year. (There are various kinds
of ID cards. County-issued state cards can get you a pass from law
enforcement. Privately issued cards get you past security at the
dispensary door.)

NorCal staffers have been telling patients that new ownership is
imminent and that other doctors will be taking Dr. Assad's place
—but it's not known when, so please call back to make an
appointment.

Assad is a tall man in his mid-50s with an eager-to-please manner. He
was born and educated in Egypt, graduating from medical school in 1979.
He moved to the U.S. in 1992 and did a residency in Internal Medicine at
Texas Tech University Medical School, then went to work for Kaiser
Permanente in Vacaville. When two women complained that Assad made
sexual moves on them, the medical board filed an accusation. Assad, who
says he was framed, accepted a probation deal from the medical board
that barred him from treating female patients for seven years.

Assad began issuing cannabis approvals in October, 2003. He was employed
initially by a dispensary operator in Oakland. In July 2004 he launched
NorCal, employing nurse practitioners and PAs to make possible a
high-volume practice. He thus got around the ban on seeing women.

"He was trying to get away with as much as he could," according
to a healthcare worker who followed Assad's career. He was
reportedly seeing 30 or more new patients per day at the Oakland office
alone, and issuing almost as many renewals. (Physicians usually specify
that approvals expire after a year, but there is no legal obligation to
impose a time limit.)

Assad's downfall stemmed from his approval of cannabis use by SW, an
18-year-old (male) whom he diagnosed with Attention Deficit Disorder in
February 2007. The case was unusual in that Assad had examined SW
himself. SW's parents complained to the medical board. The ensuing
investigation focused on whether Assad "departed from the `standard
of practice' in reaching his ADD diagnosis and cannabis
recommendation (which does not require parental approval for patients
over 18). A hearing was held in August of this year, in Oakland, before
Administrative Law Judge Mary-Margaret Anderson.

Phil Denney appeared as an expert witness for the defense but could not
bring himself to say anything positive about Assad's record keeping
or his physical exam, which consisted of a handshake. Denney contended
that an ADD diagnosis did not constitute an "extreme departure"
from the standard of care, given the symptoms described by the patient,
which included insomnia, stress, and Intermittent Explosive Disorder.
Denney also defended Assad's decision not to notify SW's regular
doctor that he was issuing a cannabis approval. (SW did not want word
getting back to his parents.)

Although Denney had treated some 20,000 medical cannabis users, the
judge assumed that highest truth resided in the pages of journals
funded by drug company ads. "When asked about medical literature
concerning the use of medical cannabis," Anderson wrote in her
opinion, "Denney was dismissive. He finds patient reports concerning
efficacy to be more useful, in part because the political climate in the
United States inhibits meaningful research… Dr. Denney's
opinionswere not very helpful."

The judge had nothing but admiration for the prosecution expert, Dr.
Barbara Neyhart, an expensively coiffed member of the faculty at UC
Davis who limits her clinical practice to women between the ages of 40
and 60. Neyhart has issued exactly one medical-marijuana recommendation
during her career, "for an elderly patient with unremitting
arthritic pain in both knees who requested the recommendaton."

Anderson wrote that Neyhart's "analysis was objective,
thoughtful, and well grounded in the facts of this case and in her
education and experience. Her explanations were consistent with the
standard of practice. Accordingly, Dr. Neyhart's opinions were
persuasive and significantly informed the factual findings." The
judge was especially impressed by Neyhart's citation of a study
linking cannabis use to mental health problems in adolescence.

The 'Script Mill Rationale

On one occasion in 2005 Hany Assad accepted Tod Mikuriya's invitation to
attend a quarterly meeting of a pro-cannabis doctors group. (The group
is now known as the Society of Cannabis Clinicians). Some of Mikuriya's
colleagues grumbled about Tod's asking Assad, whose operation they
characterized as a "script mill."

In introducing himself to the group, Assad said:

"I came from a family that disapproved of hashish. In Egypt, like
here, the white collar class looks down on working people who use
hashish. One day when I was a young man I moved some furniture and I was
suffering for three or four days. I used to wonder how did movers
—when I hired movers— how did they do that every day? I
didn't have the answer but now I have the answer. These blue collar
are using hashish for pain every night so they can sleep and do the same
thing the next day. Now I feel guilty that I was not very smart to think
about that. There is no question in my mind that it is a good medication
and a safe medication."

Assad recalled that when working as a doctor in Dakahualia, a state in
Eastern Egypt, "I never had to admit a patient for an overdose or
withdrawal. The only time I was called to admit a patient was an
overdose of hashish when the patient had overeaten and was constipated."
The remarkably benign safety profile of marijuana, Assad concluded, gave
him courage him to recommend it readily. Way too readily, it turned out.

---
Fred Gardner can be reached at plebesite.com. He edits O'Shaughnessy's,
the journal of cannabis in clinical practice.

http://www.counterpunch.org/gardner11132009.html
 
West Coast Cannabis
Image
ASA SUES LOS ANGELES

Wednesday, 03 March 2010
Medical Marijuana Advocates File Lawsuit Challenging L.A. Dispensary Ordinance Restrictive provisions amount to de facto ban on otherwise legal dispensaries Los Angeles, CA -- The country's largest medical marijuana advocacy organization, Americans... Read more...
Jackson Second Medical Marijuana Trial Will Move Forward

Saturday, 27 February 2010
This morning Jovan Jackson again went to San Diego Superior court for a preliminary hearing on the second medical marijuana trial related to the Operation Green Rx Raids orchestrated by Bonnie Dumanis in cooperation with DEA through the Integrated... Read more...
Image
Why Older Folks Are Enjoying Cannabis More

Friday, 26 February 2010
Why Growing Numbers of Baby Boomers and the Elderly Are Smoking Pot http://www.alternet.org/story/145808/   Conventional wisdom dictates that as younger generations slowly replace the old, conservative social traditions are jettisoned. This may be... Read more...
Image
Bryan Epis Back to Prison for Over 7 Years for Providing Medicine

Tuesday, 23 February 2010
Chico pot grower heads back to prisonBy Denny Walshdwalsh@sacbee.comPublished: Tuesday, Feb. 23, 2010 - 12:00 am | Page 1Bhttp://www.sacbee.com/2010/02/23/2557044/chico-pot-grower-heads-back-to.html----------Photo -Photo caption - Bryan Epis is... Read more...
DPFCA: UC Studies Show Marijuana Has Therapeutic Value, Reports to Legislature

Wednesday, 17 February 2010
http://health.ucsd.edu/news/2010/2-17-medical-marijuana.htmNews ReleaseDate:   February 17, 2010UC Studies Show Marijuana Has Therapeutic Value, Reports to LegislatureFirst results in United States in 20 years from clinical trials of... Read more...
Allison Margolin: Follow spirit of pot law

Monday, 25 January 2010
By Allison MargolinAllison Margolin is a criminal defense attorney practicing state and federalcriminal law in Los Angeles.Updated: 01/24/2010 08:47:26 PM PSTON Thursday, the California Supreme Court voted to safeguard the rights ofmedical... Read more...
NYT: Cannabis Research Discouraged

Wednesday, 20 January 2010
Researchers Find Study of Medical Marijuana DiscouragedBy GARDINER HARRISJanuary 19, 2010Despite the Obama administration’s tacit support of more liberal statemedical marijuana laws, the federal government still discourages researchinto the... Read more...
Image
WSJ: Is Marijuana Medicine?

Wednesday, 20 January 2010
LIFE & STYLE JANUARY 18, 2010 Is Marijuana a Medicine? Getty Images Dave Warden displays the wares at a Los Angeles marijuana dispensary.   IS MARIJUANA A MEDICINE?Charlene DeGidio never smoked marijuana in the 1960s, or afterward. But a year ago,... Read more...
ABC NEWS: Poll Shows 81% Support Cannabis Medicines

Wednesday, 20 January 2010
High Support for Medical Marijuana ABC News/Washington Post Poll: 81 Percent Support Legalizing Marijuana for Medical Use ANALYSIS By GARY LANGER Jan. 18, 2010—   Eight in 10 Americans support legalizing marijuana for medical use and nearly half... Read more...
Image
New Jersey On Medical Marijuana: We’re Not California

Tuesday, 12 January 2010
By Jacob Goldstein New Jersey’s legislature passed a bill yesterday to legalize medical marijuana, and Gov. Jon Corzine has said he’ll sign it into law before leaving office next week. Marijuana is now legal for some patients in more than a... Read more...
Assembly committee OKs recreational marijuana

Tuesday, 12 January 2010
Wyatt Buchanan, Chronicle Sacramento BureauTuesday, January 12, 2010(01-12) 11:09 PST Sacramento - --A bill to legalize adult recreational use of marijuana - and allow the drug to be sold and taxed in California - cleared a key hurdle this... Read more...
MEDIA ADVISORY: Ring in the New Year Rally- January 4th, 2010

Thursday, 31 December 2009
Media Advisory “Ring in the New Year Rally and Protest” Medical Cannabis Peaceful Rally and Protest in Oakland January 4th at Noon (Press Conference to Begin at 12:20 p.m.)   By: Medical Cannabis Activist and Political Prisoner Mickey Martin,... Read more...
Information On The Proposed Los Angeles Medical Marijuana Ordinance

Wednesday, 23 December 2009
INFORMATION ON THE PROPOSEDLOS ANGELES CITY MEDICAL MARIJUANA ORDINANCEHOW YOU CAN PARTICIPATE IN THIS HISTORIC LEGISLATION Perhaps the most striking thing about the proposed ordinance, is that the City of Los Angeles wants medical marijuana... Read more...
Los Angeles City Council To Vote On A Medical Marijuana Ordinance

Wednesday, 23 December 2009
HEADING DOWN THE HOME STRETCH:LOS ANGELES CITY COUNCIL TO VOTE ON AMEDICAL MARIJUANA ORDINANCEIN JANUARYBy ResipsaDecember 17, 2009 Los Angeles, CA In one of the most contentious discussions about medical cannabis the Los Angeles City Council has... Read more...
Image
RING IN THE NEW YEAR! PEACEFUL CANNABIS RALLY ON JANUARY 4TH IN OAKLAND!

Friday, 18 December 2009
On January 4, 2010, cannabis patients, activists, supporters, providers, and concerned citizens will descend on Oakland's Federal, State, and City buildings to demand accountability from these government agencies. Details are still being worked out... Read more...
Should Cannabis Be Legalised?